The Government To The Rescue?

Some large cities and states are seeking help from the federal government. So far, help has not been forthcoming. We expect this to change soon, because budgetary cutbacks by municipalities will put additional pressure on an already weak economy. There is increasing talk of helping municipalities with infra-structure needs such as bridges, roads, and energy.

We believe the best option for the government in assisting municipalities is to create some sort of replacement for the bond insurers. This would help reduce borrowing costs for municipalities, and would ensure that financing would be available to issuers who need to borrow. It would also help to restore confidence in the financial system by eliminating the de-leveraging that has been taking place in most asset classes.

What Did The Government Do Wrong Last Year?

When the government let Lehman go down in mid-September, the strains on our financial system were so great the credit markets ground to a halt. The counter party risk involved with Lehman and other counter-parties were revealed to all, and resulted in widespread fear throughout the system. The government greatly under-estimated the systemic risk they were taking when they let Lehman collapse.

The government also didn’t understand how important the bond insurers were to our funding mechanism for credit. Our system relied on guarantees to create AAA credits in the short term markets. These AAA ratings were the key to cheap funding by all sorts of borrowers. The demand for money market eligible paper was so great, a financially strong issuer could borrow at low rates. This system worked well for years and allowed for various leveraged strategies to exist which lowered borrowing costs for most borrowers. The financial shock to our system from rising default rates of Sub-Prime mortgages, and falling housing prices put immense stress on guarantors who had become over-exposed to this market. As insurers got downgraded, investors began to panic in the short-term markets. First, funding dried up for SIV’s which funded Sub-Prime mortgages. Next, investors sold insured notes by FGIC and XLCA, and bought notes guaranteed by MBIA and AMBAC as it became clear these companies were going to lose their AAA ratings. This steady stream of downgrades of guarantors created an absolute panic in the short term markets as they realized no AAA rating was safe. This resulted in the collapse of the Auction Rate Securities market. As funding costs sky-rocketed in the short-term markets de-leveraging took place in earnest in all fixed income markets. We believe the government’s lack of understanding of the importance of guarantees in the short-term markets led to our funding mechanism breakdown last year. This created a crisis in confidence, de-leveraging, and the decline in asset values.

Inflation Worries

Investors are becoming increasingly concerned about inflation as a result of the massive governmental intervention which is taking place. Their argument is that “the government is running large deficits and the money supply is growing out of control”. They feel sooner or later we will experience inflation, and they are worried about a dramatic fall in the dollar and the possibility of hyper-inflation as a result. We feel inflation fears are currently overblown since the economy is still contracting and is very weak. The chart below shows the Chicago Fed National Activity Index. It is a combination of several leading indicators and shows how we are doing

compared to the long term trend growth rate of the economy which is represented by the line at 0. Inflationary warnings flash when this indicator is at 0.7%, and recession is likely to occur when the index falls below –0.7%. The current reading is about –3.4% which is nowhere near the inflationary warning level of 0.7%.


Most investors have grossly underestimated the deflationary forces at work in the economy due to deleveraging caused by tight money conditions in a highly leveraged economy. The cheap funding through the short-term markets which allowed leveraging to take place has disappeared, because the bond insurers are no longer AAA rated credits. This has reduced the supply of credit dramatically because the “borrow short and lend long” trades no longer work. These trades represented the “Shadow Banking System” which funded leveraged buy-outs, no money down housing loans, and hedge fund activity. The contraction of this form of financing has led to economic weakness, which has caused the velocity of money to fall, which has offset the increase in the money supply. It will most likely take a long period of time for these forces to work themselves out before inflation becomes a problem.