Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Nominal GDP and Inflation


The Current View of Inflation
Investors have become increasingly concerned about future inflation due to massive governmental intervention and growth in the money supply. These investors argue that the large increase in money supply has to go somewhere, and it will cause inflation. They may also argue that this increase in money will cause the dollar to go down, which will in turn cause prices to rise even further. They frequently feel compelled to throw in their thought that the deficits we are currently running are so large, that the only way out of this situation is to inflate our way out. This is currently the consensus view. While this view may be intuitively obvious to most investors, we believe high rates of inflation are not necessarily a foregone conclusion.

Review of Inflation
The chart below shows the annual rates of inflation as measured by the U.S. CPI Index for Urban Consumers on a non-seasonally adjusted basis since 1926 through 2008.
This information is available from the U.S. Department of Labor and may also be found in the Ibbotson SBBI 2009 Yearbook. The average annual rate of inflation during this time period was 3.0%. During the period from 1926-1933 we experienced deflation. In fact, it took until 1945 for the Consumer Price Index to get back to the level it was at in 1926. During the 1950’s and 1960’s inflation experienced a slow rise. The 1970’s saw inflation rise until it peaked at 13.3% in 1979. This was the year gold reached $850.00 per ounce and silver peaked out at $50.00 an ounce as Bunker Hunt tried to corner the silver market. WIN buttons were passed out which stood for “Whip Inflation Now”. OPEC proclaimed an oil embargo and the price of oil went shockingly high. This was an inflection point for inflation. During the 1980’s inflation steadily declined and this trend continued through the 1990’s until last summer when oil reached $150.00 a barrel. Since then the economy has continued to decline and price increases have been under control. Last year the CPI was only up 0.1% even though gas prices had reached prices of over $4.00 a gallon during the summer. Last summer many investors “knew” inflation had returned and feared interest rates were going higher. So far, during this year the index has increased 1.3% through April. The chart below shows the average annual inflation rate by decade since 1926. By looking at inflation over longer time periods the data is smoothed and we are able to see the long term trends more clearly.


Inflation and Economic Growth
Our research shows a high correlation between economic growth and inflation when the economy grows faster than trend. We used data from the Bureau of Economic Analysis to measure growth of GDP. GDP grew at an average annual nominal rate of 6.68% during the period from 1926-2008. Let’s call this the trend rate of growth for the economy in the U.S. In the chart below we compare the annual rate of growth of nominal GDP minus the trend rate by decade, and compare this growth versus trend to the CPI. The results show a high correlation. During the 1930’s the economy contracted below trend and we had deflation. During the 1940’s, 1970’s, and 1980’s the economy grew above trend and we had high levels of inflation. Economic growth during the the 1950’s and 1960’s was at trend and inflation was low. The last 20 years has shown growth below trend with declining rates of inflation.

Conclusion
Investors would be wise to pay attention to indicators which
are leading indicators of the economy such as the LEI Index or the Chicago Fed National Activity Index. These indicators are currently still showing economic weakness which is way below the trend rate for the economy of 6.68%. Inflationary pressures are not likely to appear until growth in nominal GDP approaches levels in excess of trend.