Current Credit Crisis Compared to Long Term Capital Management

Long Term Capital Management

It is interesting to compare the current credit crisis to October 1998 when Long Term Capital Management created a similar predicament in the credit markets. The table below shows the Fed in a tightening mode prior to September 1998 when LTCM exploded.

(Click below to Enlarge)

The Fed quickly cut rates 3 times during September-November, reducing the funds rate from 5.50% to 4.75% until the crisis was averted. The chart below shows the rise in yields after the Fed began to ease.

(Click below to Enlarge)

Yields continued to rise into January 2000. During this time, the yield curve steepened and the economy continued to grow. The Fed had to reverse gears and tighten again beginning in June of 1999. The premature easing that took place because of LTCM proved to be an ill founded decision for the Fed.

The Current Economic Cycle

Fixed income investment returns are closely tied to inflation and economic growth. We monitor the Index of Leading Economic Indicators (LEI) as a barometer of future economic strength, and the GDP Price Deflator as a measure of inflationary trends. The chart below shows the LEI for the period from December 1995 to the present.

(Click below to Enlarge)

The index showed no signs of slowing until early 2000. This would have been a red flag that the Fed was easing prematurely. The current situation is somewhat different. The LEI has been moving sideways since the end of 2005. We will be monitoring the LEI closely for signs of future strength or weakness. If the index begins to rise, this would be a negative for bonds. Inflation has weakened somewhat, but is still near the upper end of the Fed’s target of 2%. Recently, inflation has been showing signs of slowing. If it begins to accelerate, we would view this as a negative for bonds. Gold and oil have both been rising, which is a red flag that the Fed is easing while inflationary pressures may be building.

Conclusion

The Fed has made a pre-emptive strike by lowering rates. It is unclear if this is good for bonds. The initial reaction is not encouraging, since the long bond has sold off about 1.5 points since the announcement. The bond market is concerned that the Bernanke Fed may be lowering rates when inflation is still not under control. Time will provide us with the data to see if this was a wise decision. Hopefully it isn’t an over-reaction to the current crisis similar to October of 1998 when the Fed eased because of Long Term Capital Management even though the economy was strong.